Paragon Strategies

Home » Uncategorized » A Recruiter’s Guide to Hiring the Super Motivated

A Recruiter’s Guide to Hiring the Super Motivated

Start here

Paragon Posts

March 2014
M T W T F S S
« Feb   Apr »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Hours & Info

415-310-9894
Paragon Strategies Corporate Offices:
447 Noe Street
San Francisco, CA 94114
9 am - 6pm

Duds and rock stars are easy to spot. Here’s an assessment system to help ensure that you don’t hire the candidate who’s almost good enough.

All of the best recruiters I know use performance-based job descriptions and follow this three-part guide to hiring when assessing candidates:

Rule One: Suspend judgment for at least 30 minutes. A good first impression may compel you to seek out evidence to justify a hire, and the opposite is true for candidates who begin on the wrong foot. Counteract this natural reaction by focusing on gathering specific evidence of exceptional performance during the work-history review.

Rule Two: Probe for an “achiever pattern” indicating the candidate is in the top 25 percent of his or her peer group. Specifically, look for the following:

1. People who change jobs in order to propel career growth, not seek security or avoid problems

2. A consistent pattern of taking on difficult technical projects beyond their experience level. Managers assign their best people to tackle the trickiest challenges for a reason.

3. A history of volunteering for risky assignments that stretch skills. Success builds confidence.

4. Early-career exposure to senior executives and important projects.

5. Important jobs on multi-functional project teams. Be wary of people whose team growth plateaued early.

6. A track record of being promoted ahead of peers. Award double bonus to candidates who did so at different companies and with different managers.

7. Company or industry recognition in the form of awards, honors, advanced educational opportunities, or speaking engagements.

Rule Three: Use the information gathered in that first 30 minutes to rank candidates according to the performance-based scale below. Note that it is a nonlinear scale — in other words, Level 3 is reserved for the top 25 percent of people doing similar work. These are not C students; they are great hires.

From a practical standpoint, it’s impossible to accurately assess a person in 30 minutes. However, half an hour is plenty of time to identify your Level 1s and Level 5s. Everyone else will fall in the Level 2-4 range. You should spend the next hour or two of the interview trying to make sure you don’t hire a Level 2.

Avoiding the 1s is easy. You have to dig deep to avoid hiring a Level 2. Here is what you’re looking for:

Level 1 — Bottom Third: This candidate has neither the skills nor the motivation to do the work at a consistent level of quality. He or she gets hired when the interviewer emphasizes personality or first impressions, and fails to conduct due diligence (i.e., reference checking, background verification).

Level 2 — Bottom Half: This candidate has the basic skills to do the work, but is not highly motivated. Suss this out by asking where the person took the initiative, went the extra mile, or volunteered to lead an important project. If you don’t find much, categorize the person as a Level 2. These people get hired by box-checking skills and riding the coattails of first impressions or intuition.

Level 2.5 — Average: There is little evidence the person is out-performing his or her peers on any factors.

Level 3 — Top 25%: This person demonstrates an “achiever pattern” indicating that she has been recognized by colleagues as a top performer and a promotable person.

Level 4 — Top 5-10%: It’s nearly impossible to determine whether someone is a Level 4 in just 30 minutes. Clues include getting some major company award like a fellowship, a special grant, extraordinary bonus or special assignment.

Level 5 — Rock Star, Top 1-5%: Rock Stars typically have a track record of rapid promotions in different situations, always being assigned to the most important projects and succeeding, or receiving industry-wide recognition.

Follow the “No 2s” rule to ensure everyone you hire is a Level 3, 4 or 5. Some will be all-stars, some will be MVPs, and everyone else will make the starting team.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Learn more at Paragon Strategies Training, Coaching and Consulting programs @ http://www.paragonstrategies.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Paragon Strategies on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,333 other followers

Paragon Strategies

%d bloggers like this: